Showing posts with label Harvard Business School. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Harvard Business School. Show all posts

Monday, May 6, 2013

The marriage of a “virtuous mouse” and a “wealthy elephant”

Professors James E. Austin and Herman B. “Dutch” Leonard, of Harvard Business School discuss whether the marriage of a “virtuous mouse” and a “wealthy elephant” work to the benefit of both

Q: How can elephants protect the mouse’s value & brand integrity?

JA/DL: The more effective large companies have recognised that preserving the social icon’s distinctive culture and business approach is essential to preserving its key success factors. Consequently, they retain a large degree of organisational independence so as to prevent “contamination” of the social technology. This stands in contrast to the common approach in acquisitions to integrate and rationalise the assets into the new owner’s systems, structure, and culture. Some of the specific mechanisms used in successful small company-big comapny M&A deals include governance structures and processes that give the “mice” review and even veto power over actions by the “elephants” that might jeopardise those elements that are deemed essential to the social values underlying the brand’s integrity.

Q: What are some obstacles that companies considering these kinds of acquisition strategies need to be mindful of?

JA/DL: Avoid assuming that these acquisitions are the same as others. Failing to understand and appreciate the social value dimension of the mice’s missions or failing to respect their distinctive operating culture can create incompatibility and conflict that will probably cancel the courting or sour the marriage. Don’t look first for cost rationalisations, but concentrate on the top line growth.

Q: So, do such M&A deals create value for shareholders?

JA/DL: The marriages we have studies so far are still in their early stages, so we will need to continue observing how they unfold. Nonetheless, the emerging evidence suggests that both the virtuous mice and the wealthy elephants are well on their way to attaining their respective goals. Scaling is occurring, thereby enabling social entrepreneurs to achieve greater impact. Market penetration and positive financial results are being achieved, thereby meeting the large companies’ aspirations. There have been bumps, but it does appear that the partners are capable of learning and adjusting, and are well on their way to capturing the potential synergies.


Source : IIPM Editorial, 2013.
An Initiative of IIPM, Malay Chaudhuri
For More IIPM Info, Visit below mentioned IIPM articles
2012 : DNA National B-School Survey 2012
Ranked 1st in International Exposure (ahead of all the IIMs)
Ranked 6th Overall

Zee Business Best B-School Survey 2012
Prof. Arindam Chaudhuri’s Session at IMA Indore
IIPM IN FINANCIAL TIMES, UK. FEATURE OF THE WEEK
IIPM strong hold on Placement : 10000 Students Placed in last 5 year
BBA Management Education

Friday, May 3, 2013

The high risks of short-term management

Profs. Francois Brochet and George Serafeim of Harvard Business School, in a HBS Working Knowledge interview with Sean Silverthorne, Editor-in-Chief, HBSWK, talk about their new research findings that prove how management based on short-term goals have negative implications for both investors and company executives alike

Companies that manage for short-term gain rather than long-term growth have been blamed for everything from popularising celebrity CEOs to causing a significant chunk of the current financial crisis. New research findings suggest that short-termism might have negative effects on these companies themselves and their investors. There’s another surprise in the research: short-termism might not be as widespread as we think, and a substantial number of corporations are rising to the challenge. “One important takeaway is that firms with long-term horizons exist,” says George Serafeim, Asst. Professor at Harvard Business School, coauthor of the working paper ‘Short-termism, Investor Clientele, and Firm Risk’, with HBS doctoral candidate Maria Loumioti and Assistant Professor Francois Brochet. “Many companies are being managed for the long term,” says Serafeim.

The research team was interested in several issues: Do short-term companies attract a particular kind of investor? Is investing in these firms riskier than investing in companies with longer-term time horizons?

Their first order of business was to determine a method for categorising companies on the short-term/long-term continuum. The answer came in the very words used by executives to discuss their companies. Brochet, Serafeim, and Loumioti studied transcripts of 70,042 earnings calls where executives discuss quarterly results with investors, analysts, and the media that were held by 3,613 firms during 2002-2008. This involved searching for 14 terms used by management such as “latter half” and “weeks” that would tip off a short-term view, versus 15 words or phrases such as “long term” and “years” that would suggest a longer time horizon approach.

The researchers then compared their list of companies on both ends of the spectrum with the companies’ actual financial and stock performance, studying indicators such as return volatility, the length of time investors held a firm’s stock, and the cost of capital. The results showed that short-term companies attracted short-term investors (bringing with them a whole new set of performance pressures on executives) and that the financial and strategic performance of these companies was more volatile – and riskier – than that of the long-termers. The team also identified industries that appear to be short-term-oriented (banking, electronic equipment, business services, and wholesale) and long-term-focused (beverages, retail, pharma, and medical goods). Companies, too, were categorised by outlook. Short-termers included Cisco, Goldman Sachs, and Chevron, while the longer horizon outfits included Coca-Cola, Ford, and Nordstrom.

Question: In general, what relationship did you find between companies you identified as short-term-oriented, their investors, and the behaviour of their stocks? 
Francois Brochet (FB): Overall, we found a positive association between the horizon over which firms communicate and the investment horizon of their shareholders. In addition, short-term-oriented firms appear to have more volatile stock returns and higher estimated cost of equity capital – that is, greater risk. While the presence of long-term-oriented investors appears to mitigate the positive association between firms’ short horizon and the volatility of their stock, this does not apply to the association between short-termism and cost of capital. We interpret this as evidence that our short-termism measure captures a dimension of non-diversifiable risk in the economy.


Source : IIPM Editorial, 2013.
An Initiative of IIPM, Malay Chaudhuri
 
For More IIPM Info, Visit below mentioned IIPM articles